Prosecutors seek maximum sentence after Murray’s statements in pre-sentence report raise concerns; sentencing postponed until December 2
MOUNT VERNON, NY — Former Mount Vernon youth basketball coach Dwayne Murray, 63, could face a significantly longer prison sentence after a Westchester County judge raised concerns that Murray appeared to minimize his sexual abuse of a 12-year-old girl, despite previously pleading guilty to the crime.
According to a November 17 report by Jonathan Bandler of The Journal News/lohud.com, Westchester County Court Judge Robert Prisco postponed Murray’s scheduled sentencing Tuesday after reviewing statements attributed to him in a probation officer’s pre-sentence report that appeared to contradict admissions Murray made when he pleaded guilty in September.
Murray, the longtime executive director of the Mount Vernon Junior Knights youth basketball program and a former assistant coach for Mount Vernon High School’s boys varsity basketball team, pleaded guilty on September 18, 2026, to first-degree course of sexual conduct against a child, a Class B violent felony. During his guilty plea, Murray admitted to engaging in sexual conduct with the girl on at least two occasions between October 2023 and March 2024, including oral sexual conduct.
Under the original plea agreement, Murray was expected to receive 18 years in state prison, followed by 20 years of post-release supervision, and would be required to register as a sex offender. However, Judge Prisco warned Murray that the sentencing agreement was conditional upon him not being rearrested, complying with an order of protection, and not denying or minimizing the criminal conduct he had admitted under oath.
Judge Questions Murray’s Statements Before Sentencing
According to lohud.com, the pre-sentence report included statements in which Murray reportedly suggested he “might” have touched the child on one occasion, claimed he did not believe his actions were intentional, minimized the duration of the sexual contact, and characterized sexually explicit text messages discovered on the girl’s phone as being “in jest.”
Judge Prisco also challenged Murray’s reported assertion that he had not realized his conduct was illegal until investigators informed him, calling it “incredible” that an adult would not understand that engaging in oral sexual conduct with a 12-year-old child constituted a crime. The statements raised questions about whether Murray violated the terms of his plea agreement, potentially allowing the judge to impose a harsher prison sentence. Westchester County District Attorney Susan Cacace, who attended Tuesday’s proceeding, accused Murray of attempting to shift blame onto the victim throughout the investigation and of backtracking now that he understands the consequences of his guilty plea.
“You don’t have to be told by a DA investigator that what you did was criminal,” Cacace told lohud.com.
Prosecutors Christine Hatfield and Alexandra Kontos are now seeking the maximum 25-year prison sentence, which Cacace said Murray deserves. Murray’s defense attorney, Christina Hall, maintains that the original negotiated 18-year sentence should stand. Judge Prisco adjourned the case until Wednesday, December 2, 2026, giving prosecutors and the defense additional time to reach an agreement. If they cannot, the judge indicated he would hold a hearing to determine whether Murray made the statements attributed to him and whether a longer sentence is warranted.
Murray Initially Faced Additional Serious Felony Charges
The case has taken several turns since Murray’s arrest on May 14, 2025, following an investigation by the Westchester County District Attorney’s Office. On December 9, 2025, a Westchester County grand jury indicted Murray on two felony charges: predatory sexual assault against a child and first-degree course of sexual conduct against a child. Predatory sexual assault against a child carries a potential sentence of 25 years to life in prison under New York law.
Murray initially pleaded not guilty before ultimately admitting to first-degree course of sexual conduct against a child in September 2026. The precise disposition of the predatory sexual assault charge under the negotiated plea agreement has not been independently confirmed. According to News 12, investigators recovered sexually inappropriate text messages exchanged between Murray and the child. Murray reportedly began acknowledging the sexual conduct after investigators confronted him with those messages.
Allegations Became Public Before Murray’s Arrest
More than a week before his May 2025 arrest, Murray posted a video on Facebook denying any sexual misconduct and suggesting the allegations were part of a politically motivated campaign intended to damage a slate of candidates running for the Mount Vernon Board of Education, including his former fiancée.
According to lohud.com, Murray claimed that Mount Vernon Mayor Shawyn Patterson-Howard had alerted him to the allegations after receiving a text message from Greg Bonaparte, whose wife was serving as school board president and facing opposition from candidates Murray supported. The report noted that Bonaparte’s text message did not specifically name Murray, leaving questions about how Murray became connected to the allegation.
During a subsequent interview with District Attorney investigators, Murray continued denying wrongdoing, claiming he was attempting to help the girl through difficulties involving her parents. However, after investigators confronted him with sexually explicit messages recovered from the child’s phone, he began acknowledging his conduct. According to the report, Murray also suggested that the child had initiated the encounters.
School District Clarified Junior Knights’ Independence
Murray was a longtime figure in Mount Vernon’s youth basketball community, serving as executive director of the Mount Vernon Junior Knights, an independent youth basketball organization that helped develop young athletes, including players who later joined Mount Vernon High School’s basketball programs. He also coached the Junior Knights’ seventh- and eighth-grade girls’ team.
Following Murray’s arrest, the Mount Vernon City School District issued a statement on May 16, 2025, through then-Acting Superintendent Dr. K. Veronica Smith, clarifying that the Junior Knights program was not operated by or affiliated with the school district. The district acknowledged that Murray had previously served as a volunteer coach but emphasized that neither Murray nor the Junior Knights had any current affiliation with the school system. At the time, district officials also stated they had not been informed of any connection between the investigation and current or former district students.
DA Seeks Information About Possible Additional Victims
The Westchester County District Attorney’s Office has previously encouraged anyone who believes they may have been victimized by Murray, or who has information relevant to the investigation, to come forward. In announcing the criminal charges, District Attorney Cacace described the allegations as a serious betrayal of the trust placed in adults who work with children. The DA’s Office has publicly requested that anyone with additional information contact its tips line at (914) 995-TIPS (8477). There has been no verified public announcement establishing that additional victims have been identified or that new charges have resulted from that request.
Sentencing Decision Now Rests With the Court
Murray’s guilty plea is no longer the central question in the case. Instead, the court must determine whether his reported statements during the pre-sentence investigation violated the conditions of his negotiated sentence. The defense maintains that Murray should receive the originally agreed-upon 18-year term, while prosecutors argue that his statements warrant the maximum 25 years in prison. Murray is scheduled to return to Westchester County Court on December 2, when the judge will determine how to proceed with sentencing.
The case has drawn attention throughout Mount Vernon because of Murray’s longtime involvement in youth basketball and his position of trust within the community. For the families who entrusted their children to youth sports programs, the case also underscores the importance of accountability, appropriate safeguards, and protecting young athletes from adults who abuse positions of authority.
Sources: Jonathan Bandler, The Journal News/lohud.com, November 17, 2026; News 12; Westchester County District Attorney’s Office; Mount Vernon City School District.

AJ Woodson is the Editor-In-Chief and co-owner of Black Westchester, Host & Producer of the People Before Politics Radio Show, An Author, Journalism Fellow (Craig Newmark Graduate School of Journalism), Rap Artist – one third of the legendary underground rap group JVC FORCE known for the single Strong Island, Radio Personality, Hip-Hop Historian, Documentarian, Activist, Criminal Justice Advocate and Freelance Journalist
whose byline has appeared in several print publications and online sites including The Source, Vibe, the Village Voice, Upscale, Sonicnet.com, Launch.com, Rolling Out Newspaper, Daily Challenge Newspaper, Spiritual Minded Magazine, Word Up! Magazine, On The Go Magazine and several others.
All my books are available on Amazon, or you can purchase my autographed copies directly from me at www.AJROKPublishing.com. Pre-order your Autographed Deluxe Edition of “Black Women of Westchester” and the 914 Hip-Hop books (email MrAJWoodson@gmail.com for more info)
Follow me at Blue Sky https://bsky.app/profile/mrajwoodson.bsky.social and Spoutible https://spoutible.com/MrAJWoodson







