HomeCriminal JusticeFIFTEEN YEARS LATER: WHAT IS THE WESTCHESTER COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY'S OFFICE AFRAID...

FIFTEEN YEARS LATER: WHAT IS THE WESTCHESTER COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY’S OFFICE AFRAID OF REVEALING?

Published on

spot_img
spot_img
spot_img
spot_img
spot_img
spot_img

By Kenneth Chamberlain Jr.

As we approach November 19, 2026, the 15th anniversary of the killing of my father, Kenneth Chamberlain Sr., I find myself once again confronting the very institution that is supposed to uphold the rule of law, pursue justice, and maintain the public’s trust.

In September of this year, I sent both an email and a certified letter to the Honorable Susan Cacace, Westchester County District Attorney, formally requesting the disclosure of the legal instructions provided to the grand jury that considered the circumstances surrounding my father’s killing on November 19, 2011.

My request was straightforward. I wanted to know what criminal charges the District Attorney’s Office instructed that grand jury to consider and what legal standards were explained to them before they reached their decision not to indict.

In October, I received what I believed was encouraging news that the District Attorney’s Office indicated that my attorneys could file a motion seeking disclosure of those instructions and that the office would not oppose the request.

For the first time in a long time, I believed we were making meaningful progress and thought, finally, a district attorney who is prepared to demonstrate the transparency, integrity, and accountability she spoke about while campaigning for office.

Now, just days before the 15th anniversary of my father’s killing, I have been informed by my attorney that the Westchester County District Attorney’s Office has changed its position and will no longer support my motion and my question to District Attorney Susan Cacace is simple “What changed?”

What happened between October and November that caused your office to reconsider its position? What legitimate legal or public interest is served by withholding the instructions that would allow my family and the public to better understand how the law was presented to the grand jury, and perhaps most importantly, why should the public have confidence in a process that the very institution responsible for administering it appears unwilling to subject to meaningful scrutiny?

I am not requesting the identities of grand jurors and I am not seeking their private deliberations nor am I asking for witness testimony. I am asking for the legal instructions given to the grand jury, including the criminal charges prosecutors submitted for consideration.

Under New York Criminal Procedure Law § 190.25(6), legal instructions provided to a grand jury must be recorded and although grand jury proceedings are generally protected by secrecy, the law also permits a court to authorize disclosure under appropriate circumstances and I am asking that this narrowly tailored request be evaluated on its legal merits.

For nearly 15 years, my family has watched successive district attorneys speak about justice while leaving fundamental questions surrounding my father’s killing unanswered.

Under then-District Attorney Janet DiFiore, the grand jury declined to indict the officers involved in my father’s death. Under former District Attorney Mimi Rocah, we were presented with a review that, in my opinion, failed to provide the meaningful accountability and answers my family had been seeking and requests for additional information continued to encounter the barrier of grand jury secrecy and now, under District Attorney Susan Cacace, we are confronted with yet another reversal that raises more questions than it answers.

During her campaign, Susan Cacace spoke about leading an office that would be “community-minded, safety-motivated and appropriately transparent” and to me those words matter but transparency is not measured by what an elected official says during a campaign, it is measured by the decisions that official makes when transparency becomes uncomfortable.

District Attorney Cacace, I recognize that my father’s killing did not occur under your administration and you were not responsible for presenting the original case to the grand jury, nor were you responsible for no true bill in 2012 but while you may not bear responsibility for what happened then, you absolutely bear institutional responsibility for the decisions your office makes now, meaning you inherited the office, but you also inherited its obligation to the public which includes maintaining confidence in the integrity of the criminal justice system, even when doing so requires examining the decisions of your predecessors.

I am not suggesting that the grand jury was necessarily improperly instructed which is precisely why I am seeking the instructions. If the law was properly presented, let the record demonstrate that and if it was not, then the public deserves to know that as well.

What I cannot accept is being told repeatedly to trust a process while being denied the information necessary to evaluate whether that trust is justified. The rule of law cannot be a convenient talking point and it cannot be something elected officials invoke when demanding accountability from others but retreat behind when questions are directed toward their own institutions.

The rule of law must apply equally to those who enforce it and those who are subjected to it.

As November 19 approaches, I am reminded that my father was more than a headline, more than a legal case, and more than another statistic involving police violence, NY FATHERS LIFE MATTERED

Fifteen years later, I am still asking a fundamental question:

What exactly did the Westchester County District Attorney’s Office instruct the grand jury to consider in determining whether criminal charges were warranted in the killing of Kenneth Chamberlain Sr.?

District Attorney Cacace, I am asking you publicly to explain your office’s change in position and reconsider its decision not as a political favor or an act of sympathy but as a matter of transparency, institutional accountability, and public trust.

I will not be intimidated by silence, discouraged by institutional resistance and I will not abandon my father’s memory simply because the pursuit of truth has become inconvenient for those in positions of authority. The rule of law means very little if those entrusted to uphold it are unwilling to explain how it was applied.

Fifteen years later, I am not asking for special treatment. I am asking for an answer.

Kenneth Chamberlain Jr.

Son of Kenneth Chamberlain Sr.

Justice, Accountability, and Transparency are not just words, they are obligations.

— Kenneth Chamberlain Junior

“I am not anxious to be the loudest voice or the most popular. But I would like to think that at a crucial moment, I was an effective voice of the voiceless, an effective hope of the hopeless.” — Whitney Young

Latest articles

America’s Aviation System Under Scrutiny: Who Is Accountable When Technology Failures Ground the Nation?

America is supposed to have one of the world's safest and most advanced aviation...

They Didn’t Read the Book, But They Proved My Point Before It Even Came Out

The backlash to Deadly Consequences of Being Black started before the book was even...

Ayanna Pressley Puts Reparations on the Table as Pressure Builds to Challenge Hakeem Jeffries for House Speaker

Democrats are preparing to take control of the House, but will reparations finally become...

New York’s Government Overreach: When the State Goes After the Amish, Every New Yorker Should Pay Attention

The battle over religious freedom, parental rights, and government power is bigger than vaccinations....

Join The Publisher's Circle

Get Black Westchester in your inbox — free.

Join free

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

People Before Politics — Sunday Rundown